We had another idea and the littles decided they would share this one. We glued googly eyes on rocks.
Then bagged them up similarly to the cookie ones. These are some for Aiden's teachers. They read "You rock at teaching us Bible!" and "You rock at leading and loving us!"
Gavin's to his friends read "You rock at being a great friend!"
We made a few more for Aiden's class but as I was printing I ran out of magenta ink.
Blue will work just fine for a boy's valentines anyway, right? This version has a little box of conversation hearts included. Gavin's teachers even got some green ones!